shouldn't the guild tab include a guild member list and ranking?

+1 Should be in that centerish area that tells what guilds are. After the first time viewing this, who cares. Allow us to see a guild list there instead.

Comm > Guild > Guild list > nobrainer

+1

+1 but only if fancy features such as guild applications, guild stats tracking, and guild achievements tied to badges are incorporated.

+1 to original; I feel that once you have joined/created a guild, the information on the right pane becomes redundant.