Forums » General
Many people do not like stuff from their game/project being reused in other projects. They want their game to be unique. If you contributed some code under a license that would allow you to reuse it, then that becomes a non-unique object. Why this is a problem is more obvious with art assets than with code, so I'll use that for an example. Say you contributed a ship design to VO. Now, a few years later you make your own game also using that ship, or license that ship to be used by a competitor of VO. Now there is a problem, because two competing games have the same ship. It isn't necessarily a legal problem, assuming all the licensing was worked out correctly, but it is a marketing problem.
Beyond that, it would involve yet more paperwork. Things get annoying when you have a bunch of different licenses covering different chunks of your project. Especially if they aren't easily separated, or if they have a good chance of having bits and pieces spread into other areas over time.
Requiring sole ownership of contributions means that a group of potential contributors are alienated, in order to maintain simpler legalwork and better chances of being able to attract investors and potentially sell the game. It is a compromise that GS has apparently found acceptable. If I were in their shoes I would most likely do the same thing.
It sucks if you happen to be one of those who is alienated, but that is life.
Beyond that, it would involve yet more paperwork. Things get annoying when you have a bunch of different licenses covering different chunks of your project. Especially if they aren't easily separated, or if they have a good chance of having bits and pieces spread into other areas over time.
Requiring sole ownership of contributions means that a group of potential contributors are alienated, in order to maintain simpler legalwork and better chances of being able to attract investors and potentially sell the game. It is a compromise that GS has apparently found acceptable. If I were in their shoes I would most likely do the same thing.
It sucks if you happen to be one of those who is alienated, but that is life.
@Pizzasgood guess your right. meh.