Forums » Suggestions

Guild commanders can appoint LT's but can't fire LT's

Oct 17, 2010 look... no hands link
This shouldn't be, Commander's can't kick council, but they also can't appoint council.

I believe commanders can outright boot LT's down to non members, but not just regular members, or from council-lt's to just council (as im going to ask whistler to do).

I don't see any reason why this is this way, a /guild demote function, that allows commanders to fire lt's from being lt's would be nice.
Oct 18, 2010 ryan reign link
+1
Oct 18, 2010 zamzx zik link
1+

sense
Oct 18, 2010 slime73 link
/guild vote lieutenant "name" no

That demotes a lieutenant, if you are a commander.
Oct 18, 2010 look... no hands link
Really? i thought that would only add a vote to whatever total.
Oct 18, 2010 slime73 link
Nope, although it's categorized with the council vote stuff for some reason.
Oct 22, 2010 look... no hands link
cool, well maybe it should be renamed, or added some way to the list of crap that comes up when you just type /guild
Oct 25, 2010 ntli link
slime, if that works it is a bug and should be reported.

Only council should be able to demote a ltnt. (in the current system) a commander of a guild should not have total control.
Oct 25, 2010 slime73 link
As I said in your bug thread, Commanders can appoint lieutenants. It makes perfect sense that they can demote them. How does that give them total control of the guild? Commanders can't demote or appoint councilmembers.

I think you misunderstand how guilds work.
Oct 26, 2010 pirren link
+1 to OP
Oct 26, 2010 slime73 link
(+1 to renaming '/guild vote lieutenant "name" no' to '/guild demote "name"')